This drawing is believed to be a portrait of Luis Aury, found in a collection of letters saved by his sister in Paris.
 

Our Premier Pirate: Luis Aury

   

By Helen Gordon Litrico

   

This is the conclusion of a series on Luis Aury originally published in the Fall 1985 and Winter 1985-86 issues of Amelia Now.

Before entering the port of Fernandina, Aury welcomed Sir Gregor MacGregor aboard his flagship, Mexican Congress. MacGregor was the Scottish mercenary financed by U. S. business firms who, with his American recruits, had captured Fort San Carlos and taken over control of Amelia Island from the Spanish. When no more men, money or munitions were supplied by his U.S. backers, MacGregor decided to leave. He turned over authority to Ruggles Hubbard, former High Sheriff of New York, and Jared Irwin, a former U.S. Congressman from Pennsylvania. Largely through a fluke, a defense mounted by Hubbard and Irwin repelled the Spanish counterattack in the Battle of Amelia on September 13, 1817. Hubbard and Irwin were out of funds, and MacGregor's recruits left on the island were unpaid.

Fully informed and forewarned by MacGregor, Aury sailed into the port of Fernandina on September 17, 1817, accompanied by two privateers and a prize valued at $60,000. He was warmly welcomed by Hubbard, who immediately appealed for financial aid. Aury refused unless he could be supreme commander of both civil and military affairs, as he had been in Galveston. Hubbard and Irwin protested so strongly that Aury threatened to leave the island. A compromise was reached: Hubbard would be civil governor of Amelia and Aury would be commander-in-chief of military and naval forces with Irwin as his adjutant general. The flag of the Mexican Republic would fly, and Aury would take care of all back pay due to MacGregor's men. Thus, with booming cannon, forces standing at attention and a flowery proclamation from Aury and Hubbard, Amelia Island was "annexed" to the Mexican Republic on September 21, 1817.

The more respectable inhabitants of Fernandina had fled the island now taken over by an international mixture of men ostensibly supporting South American patriots but actually more motivated to plundering and pirateering. There were American, English, Irish and French adventurers, together with Aury's well-trained crews from Galveston, including 130 mulattoes known as "Aury's blacks." Trouble erupted from the start between Hubbard and the Americans and Aury and his blacks., who were garrisoned with whites. Thus, racism was one weapon in the power struggle. The population divided into the "American party" headed by Hubbard and the "French party" headed by Aury. The situation was one of almost open warfare when Hubbard fell ill with fever. With a body of armed mulattoes, Aury stormed Hubbard's quarters and forced hum to make concessions, whereupon Hubbard soon died.

One week later, 30 British ex-officers arrived, seeking to join MacGregor in the fight for South American independence. Aury treated them to a banquet before announcing that he had more officers that he could use, many of whom had to do duty in the ranks. Most of the British officers departed. The few remaining tried to organize a party of their own and acquired some defectors of the American party, which served to help Aury. Amidst the confusion, Aury saw his opportunity.
On November 5, 1817, he lined his privateers along the waterfront with their guns trained upon Fernandina, declared himself the supreme civil and military authority and imposed martial law for ten days.

Unbeknownst to Aury, President Monroe decided to invoke a secret act passed by Congress in 1811 as a preliminary to the War of 1812. The act empowered the President to expel by force any foreign power occupying Spanish Florida. At Monroe's direction, the U.S War and Navy Department issued orders in mid-November for the occupation of Amelia Island.
Meanwhile, Aury's privateering establishment prospered. Om November 20th, the agent of Lloyd's in Savannah reported that prize goods valued at a half million dollars had been sold in Fernandina.

During this time, a Venezuelan privateer, America Libre, brought to Fernandina two men quite influential in Aury's life. One was Vicente Pazos Silva, a former newspaper editor from Buenos Aires. Pazos served Aury, who was French, by writing his documents, proclamations and letters in correct if somewhat high-flown Spanish. He published, also in Spanish, what was probably the first newspaper published in Florida outside of St. Augustine.
Of even more influence and assistance to Aury was Dr. Pedro Gaul, a native of Caracas who had spent many years on two continents enlisting support of South American independence. Teaching patience and wisdom, Gaul rekindled Aury's desire to free his adopted country of New Granada (modern Colombia). Gaul proposed that Simon Bolivar and Admiral Luis Brion, Aury's arch enemy, would free Venezuela and Aury would free New Granada after first liberating the Isthmus of Panama.

Aury knew that something must be done to create the impression of a legitimate government on Amelia Island, so he called a meeting of his officers and proposed holding an election of members to constitute a legislature. Every free inhabitant of 15 days residence could vote after subscribing to an oath of allegiance.

The Assembly of Representatives met on december 1st and Irwin was elected President. To frame a republican constitution, a committee was appointed composed of Dr. Gaul, Vicente Pazos, and one M. Minder. The constitution never became operative because the intention of U.S. occupation became known at Amelia. After a momentary impulse to resist, Aury considered abandoning the island but could not because of the condition of his vessels.

After drafting with his "legislators" a preposterous document of protest to be delivered to President Monroe, Aury surrendered to the forces led by Captain J. D. Henley and Major James Bankhead on December 23rd, 1817. The American flag replaced the Mexican flag, and the U.S. controlled the island in trust for Spain.

Bankhead immediately loaded all blacks aboard one of Aury's ships and sent them off, probably to Santo Domingo. White troops, placed under strict surveillance, and white officers at large on parole, stayed almost a month after the surrender. Aury remained over two months as an unwelcome guest.

After leaving Fernandina in early 1818, Luis Aury endured another three and a half years of frustration in his efforts to help free his adopted country of New Granada from Spain. For space reasons, this conclusion will leave out all the political intrigues and deal only with several engagements which exemplify the determination and inventiveness of Luis Aury.

He set up a base of operations on the Caribbean island of Old Providence, which adjoined a small island (Santa Catalina) containing ruins of a Spanish fort. Though his first settlement was leveled by a hurricane and further plagued by famine, mutiny and fever, Aury persevered and rebuilt. In time, Old Providence had substantial houses, a church, a hospital and shops along with the restored fort.

Described as " a terror to the Spanish at sea," Aury listened to his officers on any land engagement, as most of the were trained in Napoleon's battalions.

Banned by Brion from the Colombia coast, Aury turned to Central America's fight for liberation. His squadron captured a coastal lookout from which a messenger escaped by a hidden waterway. Aury knew there must be an important settlement inland. He found the opening of the Rio Dulce, concealed by rocky palisades and deep forests. For two days he prepared small rowboats for 140 men and left 100 men to guard his seagoing vessels. All one day and one night they rowed upriver, arriving at dawn at the Spanish fort of San Felipe on Lake Izabal. Though the Spaniards were forewarned and forearmed, Aury's men captured the fort and seized great wealth in cash and indigo. Aury estimated his personal profit in the venture at $200,000.

Aury took a squadron of 14 armed vessels to attack the fortified city of Trujilo on the coast of Honduras. While most vessels kept up a steady fire directly on the target, others went down the beach and unloaded 400 men and 15 horses. They advanced in classic Napoleonic style, pushing royalists back, trench by trench, in an attempt to encircle the fortified town and concentrate the attack on the rear. The plan almost worked, but Aury's men had to retreat, repair vessels and re-embark, leaving horses behind.

Aury then approached Omoa, a town on the coast of Honduras more strongly fortified than Trujilo. It stood on the flank of a mountain protected on the beach side by a high-walled fortress with drawbridges over a moat. Seven days of frontal attack proved fruitless.

On the advice of his officers, Aury ordered two 18-pound cannons, each weighing two tons, removed from shipboard and hauled up an "unscalable" mountain to an unfortified position directly overlooking the fortress. From this advantageous height, victory was fairly well-assured. But before the demolition began, a supply vessel arrived with a message. It was the unofficial word that Aury was finally to get a commission from the vice-president of Colombia, his friend Francisco Zea, to act on the Granadine (Colombia) coast as "admiral of the navy and general-in-chief- of the armies." So elated was Aury that he abandoned the cannons left sitting on the mountain and hastily embarked for his base on Old Providence.

After waiting nearly two months, Aury learned that the official messenger was killed and his commission was lost. Zea meanwhile had been criticized by Simon Bolivar for assuming too much authority. Aury appealed to the Colombian military officer, General Montilla, who recommended his services to admiral Brion. Brion again refused him. Aury then traveled for weeks by canoe and muleback into the interior of Bogota, Colombia, to appeal directly to Simon Bolivar. Weary of battle and all the disputes, Bolivar banished Aury from the waters of Colombia altogether.

As our story ends, Brion was back in his hometown of Curacao - penniless, alone with his debts, insane and dying. Aury, who always had plenty of money from his privateering, resided on Old Providence, writing out in French a long diatribe to the Colombian congress detailing the many injustices done to him by Luis Brion.
On August 30, 1821, Luis Aury died on Old Providence. This commodore who would be a general died as a result of being thrown from a horse. He was about 33 years old.

The Luis Aury series was based on several sources, primarily, "Commodore Aury" by Stanley Kaye, published in the Louisiana Historical Quarterly in 1941.